← All storiesGamingDeveloping story

Lord of the Rings' hyped upcoming open-world RPG might break a 10-year curse

It's been how long since Middle-earth: Shadow of War?? When was the last time you played an excellent Lord of the Rings game? The landmark fantasy series is known for its epic scale, rich lore, cinematic battles, and classic good-versus-evil storyline. The same elements that define Lord of the Rings as a series, incidentally, are broadly the same things fans expect from a good RPG or action game. You'd be hard-pressed to find a single modern fantasy story that hasn't been influenced by J.R.R. Tolkien somewhere down the line. You might even have a hard time finding many games at all, in any genre, that can't be traced back to Middle-earth. So if The Lord of the Rings series is a fundamental part of the medium's DNA, why are decent Lord of the Rings games such a rarity? It's not for a lack of trying. Last year, cozy game Tales of the Shire and its surface-level homesteading landed with a thud. Survival game The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria reportedly sold at least 1 million copies — but like most trend-chasing games, there was little longevity. The Lord of the Rings: Gollum has gone down as one of the worst video game adaptation disasters of all time. Each of these games falter

1
updates in timeline
1
distinct sources
1 day
story span
May 20, 2026
latest update

May 20, 2026 → May 20, 2026

LATEST DEVELOPMENT
May 20, 2026·PolygonT2 · Outlet report
Lord of the Rings' hyped upcoming open-world RPG might break a 10-year curse

It's been how long since Middle-earth: Shadow of War?? When was the last time you played an excellent Lord of the Rings game? The landmark fantasy series is known for its epic scale, rich lore, cinematic battles, and classic…

Read original at Polygon →
ACTIVITY · UPDATES PER MONTH
May 26

1 updates from 1 source.

Showing 1 of 1 updates

Timeline (1 updates)

May 2026

1 update
May 20, 2026·PolygonT2 · Outlet reportLATEST
Lord of the Rings' hyped upcoming open-world RPG might break a 10-year curse

It's been how long since Middle-earth: Shadow of War?? When was the last time you played an excellent Lord of the Rings game? The landmark fantasy series is known for its epic scale, rich lore, cinematic battles, and…

Read original at Polygon →

Sources & evidence (1)

What this story stands on. Tier 0 is a primary record or the subject's own words; higher tiers must be attributed, never stated as bare fact.

T2 · Outlet report× 1
COVERAGE BY SOURCE
Polygon 1
STRONGEST EVIDENCE
T2 · Outlet reportPolygonMay 20, 2026

It's been how long since Middle-earth: Shadow of War?? When was the last time you played an excellent Lord of the Rings game? The landmark fantasy series is known for its epic scale, rich lore, cinematic battles, and classic…

View source →

Tier key: T0 = Primary source · T1 = Wire · T2 = Outlet report · T3 = Commentary

Related stories

GamingT2 · Outlet report

Forget open-world RPGs, no game needs to be longer than 40 hours

I’m not one to police how long a video game should be. Every game is different and begs design considerations that dictate runtime. It makes sense for Star Fox’s campaign to be…

1 update1 source
Jul 5, 2026
Latest: Forget open-world RPGs, no game needs to be longer than 40 hours · Polygon
GamingT2 · Outlet report

Baldur's Gate 3's most beloved feature is overrated and ruins the game

How thin can you stretch a story before it loses cohesion? There is a common opinion regarding 2023’s Game of the Year winner, Baldur’s Gate 3, that the storytelling and…

1 update1 source
Jul 4, 2026
Latest: Baldur's Gate 3's most beloved feature is overrated and ruins the game · Polygon
GamingT2 · Outlet report

The Co-Lead Designer of Baldur's Gate 2 Turned Baldur's Gate 4 Down and I Don't Blame Him — Baldur's Gate 3 Is Pretty Mu

After Baldur’s Gate 3’s enormous success, Baldur’s Gate 4 feels like an inevitability. That’s how the entertainment industry normally works: if a product everyone loves makes…

1 update1 source
Jun 30, 2026
Latest: The Co-Lead Designer of Baldur's Gate 2 Turned Baldur's Gate 4 Down and I Don't Blame Him — Baldur's Gate 3… · IGN
TechnologyT2 · Outlet report

Harry Potter Would Have Used a Spell to Get LEGO Hogwarts at This Price, Amazon Just Did It Without Magic

This article features deals sourced directly by Gizmodo and produced independently of the editorial team. We may earn a commission when you buy through links on the site. No spell…

6 updates2 sources4 days long
Jun 26, 2026 → Jun 29, 2026
Latest: LEGO Star Wars Isn't Done After Prime Day, With the Millennium Falcon Still at Black Friday Pricing · Gizmodo
GamingT2 · Outlet report

8 RPGs that make (almost) every side quest feel essential

From elusive frying pans to dismembered clowns Not all RPG side quests are created equal. For every captivating detour that nets you a spiffy new weapon or reveals an intriguing…

1 update1 source
Jun 28, 2026
Latest: 8 RPGs that make (almost) every side quest feel essential · Polygon
GamingT2 · Outlet report

Brandon Sanderson says fantasy learned the wrong lesson from Lord of the Rings

Sanderson was the speaker at this year's Tolkien Lecture on Fantasy Brandon Sanderson is one of the world’s most successful and prolific fantasy authors. Since the early aughts,…

1 update1 source
Jun 28, 2026
Latest: Brandon Sanderson says fantasy learned the wrong lesson from Lord of the Rings · Polygon