Ridley Scott’s New Action Sci-Fi Thriller First Reactions Greatly Divide Critics

Early reactions praise The Dog Stars’ emotional performances and striking visuals, while others criticize its slow pace and familiar story. Ridley Scott’s latest trip into the apocalypse has left early viewers split. Early reactions to The Dog Stars praise the movie's striking visuals, emotional performances and surprisingly human take on the post-apocalypse. Others have criticized its slow pacing, familiar story and underdeveloped screenplay, arguing that Scott’s direction is stronger than the material he was given. Some early viewers have praised The Dog Stars as an unusually intimate and emotionally grounded post-apocalyptic story. Phil Roberts of Future of the Force called it a “humble and emotionally weighted change of pace” for Scott on X, while MovieWeb’s Rob Sperduto called it a “surprisingly optimistic and sincere post-apocalyptic neo-Western” and praised Jacob Elordi’s vulnerability. Other critics were much less impressed. Matt Neglia of Next Best Picture argued that the screenplay undercuts Scott’s strongest work behind the camera, while The HoloFiles called the movie a generic post-apocalyptic thriller that feels too similar to The Last of Us and 28 Days Later. The spli

Aug 25, 2026 → Aug 25, 2026