← All storiesGamingDeveloping story

Star Wars 'fans' reject Luke Skywalker on top 10 characters of all time ranking

I shouldn't be upset but I'm a little upset George Lucas really nailed the casting of Luke Skywalker way back in 1976. In Mark Hamill, the filmmaker not only found the ideal young person to portray a hero wannabe, but an actual dreamer IRL who would enjoy playing an ambassador for Star Wars for 50-plus years. Speaking to him at the age of 74, Hamill is just as entranced by the magic of Star Wars as ever. So Mark, if you’re reading this, look away: you have been snubbed by the so-called fans!! In an announcement timed to May the 4th, the unofficial day of all things Star Wars, Fandom has issued what it believes are the top 10 Star Wars characters “according to fans.” The results were not collated by a poll, but rather “by examining fan engagement this past year across its Wookieepedia community.” Based on the list, the methodology is suspect, to say the least. There's no Luke, no Han, no Leia, and no Yaddle. If Fandom’s list reveals anything, it’s that the metrics of the internet have warped the concept of popularity and legacy. An impression on a wiki has very little to do with our feelings deep down and everything to do with casual fans watching, say, the finale of The Acolyte and

1
updates in timeline
1
distinct sources
1 day
story span
Apr 30, 2026
latest update

Apr 30, 2026 → Apr 30, 2026

LATEST DEVELOPMENT
Apr 30, 2026·PolygonT2 · Outlet report
Star Wars 'fans' reject Luke Skywalker on top 10 characters of all time ranking

I shouldn't be upset but I'm a little upset George Lucas really nailed the casting of Luke Skywalker way back in 1976. In Mark Hamill, the filmmaker not only found the ideal young person to portray a hero wannabe, but an actual dreamer IRL…

Read original at Polygon →
ACTIVITY · UPDATES PER MONTH
Apr 26

1 updates from 1 source.

Showing 1 of 1 updates

Timeline (1 updates)

April 2026

1 update
Apr 30, 2026·PolygonT2 · Outlet reportLATEST
Star Wars 'fans' reject Luke Skywalker on top 10 characters of all time ranking

I shouldn't be upset but I'm a little upset George Lucas really nailed the casting of Luke Skywalker way back in 1976. In Mark Hamill, the filmmaker not only found the ideal young person to portray a hero wannabe, but…

Read original at Polygon →

Sources & evidence (1)

What this story stands on. Tier 0 is a primary record or the subject's own words; higher tiers must be attributed, never stated as bare fact.

T2 · Outlet report× 1
COVERAGE BY SOURCE
Polygon 1
STRONGEST EVIDENCE
T2 · Outlet reportPolygonApr 30, 2026

I shouldn't be upset but I'm a little upset George Lucas really nailed the casting of Luke Skywalker way back in 1976. In Mark Hamill, the filmmaker not only found the ideal young person to portray a hero wannabe, but an actual dreamer IRL…

View source →

Tier key: T0 = Primary source · T1 = Wire · T2 = Outlet report · T3 = Commentary

Related stories

TechnologyT2 · Outlet report

Ruggable Star Wars collection: Order ahead of 'The Mandalorian and Grogu' release

TL;DR: Ruggable has released a new Star Wars-inspired collection. Order head of the release of The Mandalorian and Grogu. Fancy celebrating May 4th with a spruce up of your home…

3 updates3 sources6 days long
Apr 30, 2026 → May 6, 2026
Latest: We Visited Disneyland's Galaxy's Edge to Experience the Original Trilogy Timeline - Here's What We Thought · IGN
GamingT2 · Outlet report

The Expanse creators will cap their new series at three books, so they don't fall into a Star Wars rut

'Star Wars is never going to stop. And Star Trek is the same way. If you have a big universe, it is expected you will just keep dipping in that well.' Reading The Mercy of Gods…

2 updates1 source12 days long
Apr 23, 2026 → May 5, 2026
Latest: The Expanse creators' Star Wars novel has a whole new angle on Han Solo · Polygon
GamingT2 · Outlet report

Disney's controversial, canceled Star Wars show is suddenly a streaming hit (and we think we know why)

The past few weeks have been a great time to be a Star Wars fan thanks to a delectable new Darth Maul outing in Star Wars: Maul — Shadow Lord. There's also been the promotional…

4 updates2 sources11 days long
Apr 24, 2026 → May 5, 2026
Latest: As Star Wars Viewing Figures Show a Disturbing Lack of Faith in the Sequels, Fans Discuss Where Disney Goes… · IGN
TechnologyT2 · Outlet report

Hot Toys' New Ahsoka Figure Is Weird for All the Wrong Reasons

Hot Toys’ eerily accurate action figures always have something a bit uncanny about them. Sometimes the accuracy goes beyond detail and into almost homunculus-esque territory; in…

1 update1 source
May 4, 2026
Latest: Hot Toys' New Ahsoka Figure Is Weird for All the Wrong Reasons · Gizmodo
TechnologyT2 · Outlet report

The best Star Wars Day deals

Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Posts…

1 update1 source
May 4, 2026
Latest: The best Star Wars Day deals · The Verge
ScienceT2 · Outlet report

Scientists discover 27 potential new planets that orbit two stars in solar systems far, far away

On ‘Star Wars day’, researchers more than double the number of potential known ‘circumbinary’ planets like the fictional Tatooine, home to Luke Skywalker Astronomers have…

1 update1 source
May 4, 2026
Latest: Scientists discover 27 potential new planets that orbit two stars in solar systems far, far away · The Guardian